Sal's Authentic New York Pizza

Our rating 

User rating 

8 reviews
Venue Image
4A Commerce Street,
Auckland Central
Auckland,


+64 9 379 7257

The ViewAuckland Review

StarStarStarStarNo Star
Review byJono Park26/04/2011

I don't actually know when Sal's Authentic New York Pizza arrived in Auckland. All I know is that when I got back from a long stay in London last year, this cheeky little upstart had arrived on K Rd and you could grab pizza by the slice and eat it outside on a bar leaner with a pint. What a homecoming!

Sal's is very much a new spin on an old school New York pizzaria. Both branches are pretty much identical, decked out in exposed brick, wood and stainless steel. Both are also great to pop in with a small group of friends though Commerce St is probably the better bet for a booth.

The pizzas are massive in size, which is apt given their historical home. It's a definite 'hold high, eat low' kind of pizza that is super thin but not crumbly. My personal eating style is to fold a slice in two and have a kind of pizza sandwich. The pepperoni is great and has a lovely spicy kick to it (and along with most of the ingredients has been imported from the US). You can grab these by the slice ($5) or by the whole (18 inch starting from $24).

The other pizzas include the classic cheese, meatball, sausage and veggie varieties as well as a recent chicken addition to the menu. I've tried most of these and they're definitely up there (though the pepperoni still takes some beating).

The sides are almost better - whatever you do, grab garlic knots as a side. If they're cooked right (and I must say that sometimes mine have been underdone) they are a beautiful steaming crunchy nugget of garlic goodness. If you don't go for the pepperoni pizza but still have a craving, then the weighty pepperoni wheels are perfect to fill the gap. Be aware though that they are bigger than they look so you may not have room for much more.

One area that Sal's could scrub up on a bit is the turnaround at the counter. It does sometimes take a LONG time to get your order in even when it's not busy, something which I think could be rectified by simply taking the order then telling customers how long it will be rather than waiting around until the garlic knots have heated through before moving to the next customer. I'd maybe ring ahead if you're after something straight away.

I've heard people say that Sal's is the best pizza in Auckland. I'm not sure that's true (Toto's, Dante's and Epilito's would all be up there), but Sal's Authentic New York Pizza is still pretty damn good especially if it's the NY style of pizza you're after. It may not have massive variety, but it does have massive tasty portions and perhaps that's all that matters. And to be fair, pizza has never looked so cool.

Oh and keep an eye out for the new Takapuna store opening soon!

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza has been reviewed by 8 users
 
Nearest

What's near Sal's Authentic New York Pizza?

Below are the nearest 5 venues within 500 metres of Sal's Authentic New York Pizza.
Cinemas near Sal's Authentic New York Pizza (0)

Most Read Today

image
01 Auckland's Best Malls

Check out our picks of the top five malls in Auckl...

image
02 Auckland's Best Petting Zoos

We've picked out the best 5 petting farms and pett...

image
03 Mt Eden, Auckland

From the dizzying heights of the Sky Tower, it loo...

image
04 Auckland's Best Free Kids Activities

We check out the best five free kids activities in...

image
05 Auckland's Best Swimming Pools

We have a look at five heated swimming pool comple...

Content updated: 25/02/2020 11:09

Restaurant Reviews

Get Onboard

Make It A Date

Connect

Latest Restaurants User Reviews

  • Dennys Restaurant
    went there 1/1/20 for dinner. staff not friendly,wouldnt try to h...

    cailean on 3/01/2020 @ 11:07 p.m.
  • Sweet and Me
    If you like both home baked treats and the flavours of the Pacifi...

    LisaS_LocalHero on 22/12/2019 @ 5:37 p.m.
  • Al Forno
    Last week I was back at Al Forno for the first time since the new...

    LisaS_LocalHero on 31/10/2019 @ 7:19 p.m.
  • Manuka Restaurant
    Popped into Manuka in Devonport for a coffee yesterday and had a ...

    LisaS_LocalHero on 10/10/2019 @ 4:08 p.m.
  • La Gondola
    Just ordered via Uber Eats. I have never seen smaller portions in...

    aberdaugledau on 21/09/2019 @ 9:03 p.m.
Hitwise Award Winner